• Sun. Nov 22nd, 2026

Marxist Night School Lawsuit

Aug 15, 2025

A spectre is haunting the Administrative Court

The Hamburg court doubted Karl Marx’s loyalty to the constitution. Is every Marxist study group now under suspicion?
By Amira Klute
Hamburg, taz | It felt like a victory for all Marxist study groups in the country. On April 8, 2023, the “Marxist Evening School — Forum for Politics and Culture” (Masch) won its case against the State Office for the Protection of the Constitution (Verfassungsschutz) in the Hamburg Administrative Court.

The court ruled that the Office could no longer classify the Hamburg association as left-wing extremist. Masch successfully challenged its mention in the Office’s 2021 report, which had caused it to lose its non-profit status that same year. According to those present, a cautious euphoria filled the courtroom. People left with an unfamiliar feeling of political victory.

It’s now clear: this legal victory could backfire—and become a threat to all Marxist study groups in Germany. The reason lies in the Hamburg court’s written justification for the ruling from July 10 (courts usually publish detailed justifications only weeks later). Its content is surprising.

Although the court confirms the decision in favor of Masch, calling its inclusion in the Office’s report unconstitutional, this is solely due to the members’ lack of an “actively combative stance” (aktiv-kämpferische Haltung) capable of genuinely harming the constitution.

Court considers Marx an opponent of the constitution
Masch has existed since 1981. In Hamburg, it’s known for its annual study groups on the first volume of “Capital,” but it also publishes books and holds discussions, often in rooms at Hamburg University. The organization positions itself as an heir to the traditions of workers’ educational associations and Marxist schools, claiming a non-dogmatic and critical approach to Marxist theory.

The Office for the Protection of the Constitution suspected the association, among other things, because of its founding by the German Communist Party (DKP) and ongoing close ties. The court already dismissed these accusations in April, noting that today only 1 of Masch’s 26 members belongs to the DKP.

However, the detailed written verdict goes further. The court examines the question: is the study of Marxist theory fundamentally compatible with the Constitution of the Federal Republic of Germany? Its conclusion: “The plaintiff’s activity, focused on the theories of Karl Marx, is fundamentally opposed to the free democratic basic order (freiheitliche demokratische Grundordnung, FDGO).”

The fact that Marx’s works and teachings form the core of Masch’s activities is already evident from the name “Marxist Evening School,” the court concluded. The problem is that: “The social theory founded by Marx (…) in key aspects is hardly compatible with (…) the principles of the FDGO.” In the oral announcement of the verdict in April, the court had not yet argued this thesis.

A threat to all Marxist study groups
Lawyer Ridvan Çiftçi, who represented Masch, considers the court’s argumentation irresponsible. It states: if a group primarily studies Marx, it is fundamentally against the constitution. In Masch’s case, this is only permissible because the group is not influential enough and not “actively combative” in its attitude.

In Çiftçi’s assessment, this is a threat to all Marxist study groups in Germany: “Any association that primarily references Marx can become an object of surveillance.” Thus, the verdict, with which Masch successfully challenged its status as opponents of the constitution, has potentially become a boomerang and a legal regression.

Other courts have recently treated Marx’s theory much more leniently. For example, the Berlin Administrative Court, in a case brought by the newspaper Junge Welt against surveillance by the Office, ruled: a Marxist orientation alone does not necessarily imply striving against the FDGO, and revolution can be a “radical, yet within the framework of the Basic Law, transformation of society” (ruling from July 18, 2024).

The Hamburg court sees it differently. It is convinced that the Marxist theory studied by Masch aims at violent overthrow, not reform. Masch’s argument that its activity is limited to criticizing capitalism was rejected by the court: it aims for a “complete transformation of the state and society along with the economic system” (a quote from the association’s website).

Was Marx misunderstood?
The problem with Marx lies in the “dictatorship of the proletariat,” argues the court, having consulted a state online lexicon. It “inevitably excludes other population groups from participation in shaping political will and the indirect exercise of state power.” That is—undemocratic!

Masch member Michael Hopp considers this a complete misunderstanding: “The court acts as if Marx wrote his texts yesterday.” Furthermore, Marx can quite be considered a democrat—especially if one doesn’t limit oneself, like the court, to the pamphlet “The Communist Manifesto.” The mature Marx emphasized that the means of change must correspond to the historical situation.

“Today Marx would recommend anything but storming the Bundestag with hordes,” says Hopp. The court also underestimates Marxist theory as a tool of analysis and the essence of Masch as an educational institution: “The simplification is that they attribute to us a transition from word to deed. But we precisely study the word and reflect.”

Is capitalism in the Basic Law?
The court’s decision also touches on a question that has regained prominence after the “Expropriate Deutsche Wohnen & Co” initiative: to what extent does the Basic Law (from which the FDGO derives) prescribe a capitalist system for the Federal Republic of Germany?

Masch’s argument (referencing political scientist Wolfgang Abendroth) about the Basic Law’s neutrality in economic policy was deemed unconvincing by the court.

Questions remain: Is any introductory course on Marx in the first semester now suspect? What exactly does “actively combative” mean? Does radical criticism of society contradict the constitution? To clarify this, Masch plans to do what it does best: hold a discussion.

Source: https://taz.de/Klage-der-Marxistischen-Abendschule/!6101920/

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *